Tuesday, 02.05.08

Death to the downloader

Afghan student option 1 (SHAH MARAI - AFP - Getty Images).jpg

Shah Marai/Getty Images

And US college students think they have it rough when caught downloading illegally.   By now, what rankles most about these calls for death sentences -- for naughty novels, misnamed teddy-bears, scandalous downloads -- is not just that they happen, but that the weird-beards of radical Islam have made them seem routine.  Is every act of violence and religious perversity capable of seeming normal through repetition?  How frightening to think that we might be subject to this inuring effect, if the same courts decided to enforce, say, the rules concerning slavery in the Koran.  To compensate for this creeping change in the terms of the argument, we defenders of heresy need to escalate our denunciations each time an atrocity like this is likely to happen.  Regrettably, the denunciations have instead become quieter and less impassioned instead.

First they came for our novelists...

Daniel C. Dennett chides us for not having resisted more forcefully when the Ayatollah tried to have Salman Rushdie whacked, 19 years ago next week.

 

Friends like these

Jacob Sullum notes that even the student's defenders defend him only on the narrowest grounds -- his trial wasn't fair, or he didn't blaspheme. Who cares about free speech?



Copyright © 2007 by The Atlantic Monthly Group. All rights reserved.