Friday, 02.15.08

The scorched earth primary fight

HRC 3 (Rick Gershon - Getty Images).jpg

by Rick Gerson / Getty Images

Hillary Clinton is going to have a comeback. A respectable showing in Wisconsin will propel Clinton forward in Ohio and Texas, where she enjoys deep reservoirs of support and demographic terrains that play to her strengths. So why, ask her Democratic critics, is her campaign so aggressively pushing the idea of seating delegates from Michigan and Florida? Keep in mind that all candidates agreed not to contest these elections as a nod to the first-in-the-nation caucus and primary states, and that there was an understanding that delegates selected in these uncontested primaries would not be seated. To many, this smacks of changing the rules in the middle of the game. Julian Bond, ostensibly neutral in the Democratic race, has argued that failing to seat the delegates would represent an effort to deny minority voters their basic rights -- an entirely novel charge that wasn't raised earlier on, before Obama established a small but significant lead. Obama supporters are horrified. 


Yet it's worth remembering another alleged attempt to disenfranchise voters: the contested presidential election of 2000. We have good reason to believe that a majority of Florida's voters intended to support Al Gore, but a statewide machine recount was the only neutral way to adjudicate the result. Anything else would inevitably devolve into a struggle for advantage. And the machine recount, alas, gave us George W. Bush as the winner. Neutral rules disappoint everyone at some point or another, and that's part of their charm.

A Delegate Deal

E.J. Dionne Jr. argues that Michigan and Florida will have to be counted no matter what. The best way to avoid a bruising battle is to have some kind of re-vote.

 

Clintonian Cynicism

Ezra Klein accuses the Clinton camp of cynically changing the rules for the sole purpose of gaining an edge.

 

Penn's Woodshed

Josh Marshall tears into the Clinton campaign for delegate shenanigans, and for tolerating the antics of strategist-in-chief Mark Penn.

 

Unfond of Bond

Julian Bond, who has supported the Clinton effort to seat Florida and Michigan delegates, gets a stern talking-to from blogger Nonso Christian Ugbode.



Copyright © 2007 by The Atlantic Monthly Group. All rights reserved.